Brexit or a New Brentrance? - RSA

Brexit or a new Brentrance?

Comment 59 Comments

  • Picture of Leszek Sibilski
    Leszek Sibilski
  • Leadership

June’s referendum delivered what looks to some as an almighty blow to Britain’s future development. For others it signifies a new beginning and a reason to be hopeful. Anglophile and Polish-American sociologist Leszek Sibilski argues that optimism will win through and that Brexit will be only a part of the never-ending human migration.

It is not my intention to judge the British voters on their decision to exit the European Union; it was their sovereign verdict on the future course of their own country, and I fully respect their choice. Now, it is time to move on and look forward. As a native of Poland and a proud naturalised citizen of the United States, like many immigrants, I know something about exits and entrances.

In my sociology lectures about globalization much of what we explore is about human migration and social resilience. While Poland was under the control of the Warsaw Pact, it only had three neighbours in addition to the natural northern border with the Baltic Sea: the Soviet Union, Czechoslovakia and the German Democratic Republic. Upon the disintegration of the Warsaw Pact, the People’s Republic of Poland became the Republic of Poland, and our neighbours disappeared from the maps. Poland now shares its borders with completely different countries namely: Germany, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, Belarus, Lithuania and Russia. This dynamic process of the formation of new nations started in Poland with the Solidarity Movement of almost 10 million strong. I tease my students by telling them that Poland is pondering whether, for the sake of the Mediterranean Sea, it should get rid of the cold and polluted Baltic Sea.

These changes hailed a geo-political earthquake of biblical proportions, but the people of Eastern Europe survived it intact, and have thrived enjoying democracy and the free market. Likewise, post-Brexit, the people of the United Kingdom will find ways to move on. I am a big fan of the British people; they are highly competitive and if they stick to their values and traditions, this last month will only be remembered as an emotional hiccup in their very rich history. Somehow, I sense that the Brits will turn Brexit into Brentrance to a new future.

The day before the vote on leaving or remaining in the 28 nation block, I noticed a Facebook exchange between two of my colleagues: one of whom is British and works in Germany, and the other a French person working for the same company in the HR department. The French person jokingly wrote: “In case the UK is out of the EU please make sure to secure the permit for work by Friday morning”. The reply was funnier: “On Friday? You will be on strike!” Resilience and humor will make a huge difference in this British transition into separation from the EU. 

Another sociological phenomenon from the Polish exit from the Warsaw Pact was that most of those who fought for democracy and free market left Poland after achieving the ultimate goal: Poland free of communism. A massive West migration occurred, settling in West Europe or North America or even in Australia.

Once while on a long layover at Heathrow, I decided to have sushi, served by Polish waitresses in a Japanese restaurant. I am predicting the same development with some of the UK citizens who will be migrating in the same directions as the Poles did in the past with the great advantage of having excellent knowledge of British-English, which is highly appreciated around the world. The American entertainment industry and Hollywood have been dealing with this pattern for a while but for different reasons. We will see the disappointed Brits exchanging their expired EU passports for the Green Cards and US Passports. The great human migration still continues, and no wall or refugee camps will stop it. Mobility is the essence of humanity. Whether we like it or not, we have to always take it under our consideration. The young men and women from the islands will start their families away from the Crown, but knowing them they will remain loyal and proud to their tradition. 

Some politicians have predicted that the UK’s decision is the beginning of the end of the European Union. I would use a stock market term instead: this is only an adjustment; some nations will leave, some will stay and new nations will join the Union. Perhaps, the ‘unthinkable’ will happen sooner than later and Russia will join the European structures. While that now sounds fanciful, did anyone in Poland in the 1980s think that Poland would not only become one of the most active and credible members of NATO, but also graduate the status of a developing country with flying colors?

 


Leszek Sibilski is a sociologist and advocate for issues related to climate change, family, public policy, global poverty, youth, and role of women in society.

Join the discussion

59 Comments

Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

  • Most major decision can have problems, however if Britain feels like they need a change they are entitled to do so. Although there might be problems with this transition, the overall outcome could be neutral for all parties effected . 

  • Throughout the history, Great Britain has always been a strong nation. Just because the Great Britain decided to leave the European Union does not guarantee that they will fall. Economically it's hard for a nation who's already developed and powerful to fall down immediately. Even if the prediction does come true, it will probably take much longer for it to fall down. Right now for us, it's hard to take in the fact that Great Britain left EU, however, sometimes change is necessary in order for a country to grow and become stronger. This change might not be a failure as people predict. It might take a different path and become much more united and gain success. At the end, I feel like the Great Britain was like a caged bird that was finally set free. They can now make changes to their country without having to get permission from other nations who are part of the EU. 

  • Probably the greatest challenge in assessing the impacts ofEU exit on migration is the fact that we do not yet know what kind ofrelationship would replace EU membership. There could be some kind of agreementthat included free movement between Uk and EU citizens. If this happened in theUK, the impacts of Brexit on UK migration could be relatively limited but Onthe other hand, EU withdrawal could mean the end of free movement and theintroduction of admission requirements for EU citizens who want to live andwork in the UK and for UK citizens to work in the EU countries, These couldmake migration harder and long way to work and live in UK or EU.  I would say it might hurt more the UK citizensthan EU citizens.

  • My father was the first generation born in America from a long line of Scottish coal miners. There's not much of a job market in Scotland - for generations Scots have been migrating all over the world to make better lives for their families. Obviously not a phenomena isolated to Scotland, as the article points out, migrating is human nature and we have been doing such for our entire existence as a species. The Brexit itself doesn't mean significantly more people are going to pack up and leave Britain - the same process of people migrating will continue as it has for oliticalnegligibleturbulent

  • Change is good, even if a great nation is leaving the EU won't mean the world will fall apart. Britain use to be one of the worlds powerful force so i strongly agree that they will bounce back  from leaving the EU. They may have some difficulties or hardships but i agree they will adjust.Plus it's not such a bad thing change can be good especially without borders or something holding them back people of Britain will experience a new lifestyle with new opportunities.

Related articles

  • Shared wisdom is all we need

    Trevor Hudson

    Ancient wisdom offers many learnings as we develop future-proofed leadership. Here, Trevor Hudson suggests it might even be found in unexpected places.

  • The incomplete leader

    Justin Russell

    Justin Russell reflects on his podcast series, Lessons in Leadership, on good leadership in the public sector

  • Democracy at work

    Jeremy Fox

    Hand the company over to the workers? Madness said the critics. But Jeremy Fox’s exercise in democracy grew the business and made his former employees richer. The only problem? They had to be persuaded to take holidays