RSA Animate - Smile or Die - RSA

RSA Animate - Smile or Die

Comment 38 Comments

 

Acclaimed journalist, author and political activist Barbara Ehrenreich explores the darker side of positive thinking. View a video of her lecture at the RSA that inspired this animation. Download a transcript of this video (pdf)

Join the discussion

38 Comments

Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

  • Ism Schism
    "Embedded in all this is the idea that you change the physical world with your thoughts."
    It is actually the way you feel that makes a change, and it is reality being changed, not necessarily the physical world. If you don't think there is a difference between these two, how about trying some LSD or maybe mescaline and see how does that feel for real? Or you think this "suggestion" is too "radical"? A few things this lady does points alright though.
    First, we do have to try and figure out what is actually happening in this world and see what we can do about those parts that are threatening or hurtful, although I am afraid that, since most (if not all) social problems are man made, there are people who know the causes, not too mention the solutions. So going around looking for solutions that are already within someone's reach today (what's the news on the Millennium Development Goals?) seems to me as delusional as sitting and waiting for a great hand to come down from the sky with a box written "Answers to all problems" on it.
    And second, there is not one fixed truth of reality. But are we closing in on something? Is that a scientific forecast? Is reality due to reveal itself in its wholeness at a specific moment in time? And what if that something proves to be, I dunno, the fact that, done properly, people can change the physical world with their mind? I mean, isn't it somehow delusional to think human civilization is getting closer to the outer shell and it's about to brake it? What if we are not even fertilized yet?
    I don't see how and idea like Realism differs from any other be it communism, capitalism, liberalism, existentialism, materialism, or whatever isms people try to impose (or suggest, as this lady) on human thoughts and feelings. But maybe I'm blind. Anyway, you can smile or die, or die anyway. But you can always choose the way you feel while you live.

  • Love the lecture, love the animation! Brilliant. Who did the animation?

  • A little government and a little luck are necessary in life, but only a fool trusts either of them.

  • This reminds me of a tragic loss of the English language. That is the lack of distinction between scepticism and pessimism.

    Scepticism can mean to question ideas and institutions, which (especially as a scientist) is a very positive quality! Scepticism really is a virtue (unlike some other crappy virtues, such as "faith" which I have no respect for!) that should be explicitly taught in schools. Yet the word has such negative connotations by it's relation in the collective mind to pessimism.

Related articles

  • UK Black Pride: celebration and protest

    Saba Ali

    Saba Ali explains why UK Black Pride is such an important part of Pride Month, promoting diversity and Black culture while addressing the multiple forms of discrimination faced by People of Colour from the LGBTQ+ community.

  • Pride and prejudice

    Layla McCay

    There is a diversity gap in the workplace, with LGBTQ+ people still less likely to reach the top jobs. Layla McCay’s new book discusses what is going wrong, and offers insights and advice from inspiring LGBTQ+ leaders in senior roles.

  • Why the UK needs a House of Campaigns

    Richard Ellis

    Parliament is based on political parties, but most of us approach politics through the particular issues that we care about. We should open up Parliament by giving campaigning groups a bespoke presence in the heart of our democracy.